Murder of Suzy Goulart by Jermaine Holley profiled on Betrayed

Police tape

Betrayed on Investigation Discovery looks at the case of Suzy Goulart, a mother of one, who was murdered in her apartment in Fall River, Massachusetts on April 16, 2005.

The police believe that Goulart was hacked to death by Jermaine Holley after the pair had had sex.

On the day of the murder, Holley helped a friend move apartment after they were evicted following a complaint from Goulart. This was touted as a possible motive for the crime.

That evening, Goulart was spotted by a neighbor heading into her apartment with a man wearing a hoodie.

Later that night, a neighbor reported hearing a scream before noticing smoke coming from the apartment. When the police and firefighters arrived at the scene, they discovered a pot on fire on the stove and, tragically, Goulart’s dead body.

Jermaine Holley stabbed Suzy Goulart over 50 times with a hunting knife

Goulart was on lying on the floor, wearing only a shirt and holding a severed telephone line. An autopsy revealed she’d been stabbed 40 times and slashed 13 times.

Watch the Latest on our YouTube Channel

Some of her wounds were nine inches deep, and her throat had been slashed. No murder weapon was ever discovered.

Jermaine Holley was an early suspect in the case, but investigators believed they didn’t have enough evidence to make a conviction stick. The case languished for a year until a new district attorney got things moving again, and the evidence was reviewed.

Holley’s shoes matched the bloody footprints left at the murder scene. A number of residents reported seeing Holley with a knife on the day of the murder. He had even threatened several residents with the weapon.

Witnesses also stated that Holley was wearing a hoodie that matched the one worn by the man a neighbor had seen entering her apartment.

In December 2011, Jermaine Holley was found guilty of premeditated murder with extreme cruelty and was sentenced to spend the rest of his life in prison.

More from Betrayed

Follow the links to read about more horrifying murders profiled on Betrayed.

Previously on Betrayed, Donna Bocklet was a Long Island mother of two when her longtime neighbor Anthony Libardi tried to force himself on her. When she refused his advances, he throttled her to death.

Jason Ragland was due to marry his 19-year-old girlfriend Claudette Ficik when instead he murdered the aspiring architect and dumped her remains in the Oconee River in Georgia. He tried to submerge her body with a brick, which was later traced back to the construction site where he worked.

Betrayed airs Mondays at 9/8c on Investigation Discovery.

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x