Killing of Jeffrey Stephen Lee by Jordan Henries spotlighted on Twisted Sisters

Jordan Henries mugshot photo
Jordan Henries murdered her twin sisters’ boyfriend during an argument. Pic credit: Florida Department of Corrections

The death of Jeffrey Stephen Lee at the hands of his girlfriend’s twin sister, Jordan Henries, is spotlighted in the latest episode of Twisted Sisters on Investigation Discovery.

At around 5:30pm on March 9, 2017, St. Johns County police officers responded to a 911 call about a shooting at a home in the 400 block of Arricola Avenue in St. Augustine, Florida. When they arrived, they found Lee, 29, dead at the scene from a gunshot wound.

An investigation revealed that Lee had a trespassing warning for the Arricola Avenue property, where his girlfriend, Jessica, lived. When he returned to the property, he got into a physical fight with her.

Jessica then called her sister, Jordan, 25, and their mother, Debra, crying for them to come to her apartment. She told them what happened, and out of fear that Lee could kill Jessica, they rushed to her side.

When they arrived, the confrontation continued on in the front lawn between the three women and Lee. At some point during the argument, Jordan pulled out a .45 caliber handgun and fatally shot her sister’s boyfriend.

Defense attorney Terry Shoemaker stated that Jordan did not shoot Lee intentionally. The shot she fired was supposed to be a warning shot, but it ultimately struck the victim and ended his life.

Prosecutors claimed that the incident could have been avoided had Jordan not show up at her sister’s apartment with a loaded gun, and instead called 911.

Watch the Latest on our YouTube Channel

All three women involved in the domestic dispute were taken into custody for questioning. Jessica and her mother were released.

Jordan was arrested and charged with one count of second-degree murder. She was released several months later on bond and was ordered to wear a GPS monitor.

In 2018, as part of a plea deal, Jordan’s charges were reduced. She pled no contest to manslaughter with a firearm. She was then sentenced to 17 years in prison.

Jordan received credit for the 25 days she spent at the St. Johns County Jail.

Twisted Sisters — The Bloodiest Bond, airs at 10/9c on Investigation Discovery.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

Maybe he shouldn’t have terrorized his gf and her family for years. Maybe ge shouldn’t have pulled guns in them and held it to their heads (not just once, but numerous times). She made a mistake in fear, and as awful as he was, he shouldn’t have died- but how anyone could think she deserved SEVENTEEN years for this is insane. Then again, it’s Florida. So I guess that’s one and the same. They don’t serve justice down there- they just virtue signal how “tough on crime” they are. This wasn’t a crime, it was negligence done by someone who was infamously a terrible shot who didn’t take guns seriously AND who feared for her family. She should have been given probation for a couple years. Period.

2 years ago
Reply to  Genevieve

Oh, AND she immediately showed tons of genuine remorse. There are harder, cold-blooded, violent criminals who’ve never showed remorse who’ve gotten less time. This is just ridiculous. Total miscarriage of justice.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x