Alyssa Dayvault callously murdered her two newly born babies: Evil Lives Here investigates

Mugshot of Alyssa Dayvault
Alyssa Dayvault was convicted for killing her newly born babies. Pic credit: SC Dept of Corrections

Evil Lives Here is investigating the shocking murder of two newly born babies by their mother, Alyssa Dayvault, in North Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.

In November 2017, Dayvault gave birth to a baby girl in secret at her home. After the birth, she put the baby into a trash bag and threw the child away.

Approximately a year later, in December 2018, Dayvault again gave birth, this time to a boy. She again hid the birth from her boyfriend and her mother. She would later explain that she had passed out after giving birth alone and had awoken 15 minutes later to see the baby’s blue face. And again, she threw the child into a trash receptacle.

Dayvault’s actions came to light when she began to suffer medical complications from the second birth. She visited a hospital but insisted to the medical staff that she had not given birth. It was only when confronted with refutable medical evidence did she admit that she had been pregnant and what had happened to the babies.

When the investigators asked why she had thrown her babies away, she said: “Ï wasn’t thinking. I wasn’t. I was too scared.”

Alyssa Dayvault guilty of murder by child abuse

At Dayvault’s trial, the prosecutors argued that she had shown “extreme indifference for human life” by not seeking out help for either of the two babies. She could have abandoned them at a fire station or put them up for adoption. But instead, she chose to throw them away like pieces of garbage.

In October 2020, the killer was found guilty on two counts of homicide by child abuse. Dayvault was actually absent when convicted, but she turned herself in to the police a few hours after the verdict was read out.

Watch the Latest on our YouTube Channel

At sentencing, Dayvault’s lawyers argued that the judge should be lenient with their client as she had no previous run-ins with the law and was suffering from mental health issues.

A tearful Dayvault told the court, “I never meant to do anything. I made a horrible mistake. I would never do anything to harm anyone, especially a child.”

The judge sentenced her to serve two 40 year terms in prison without the possibility of parole.

More from Evil Lives Here

Follow the links to read about more shocking murders profiled on Evil Lives Here.

Steven Crittenden was a cheap hoodlum who decided to rob the home of William and Katherine Chiapella in Chico, California. During the home invasion, he beat and stabbed the couple to death. He later escaped county jail and took a hostage before being tracked down in Sacramento and finally put on San Quentin’s death row.

Delbert Shafer had taken his son, David Shafer, into his home in Leetonia, Ohio, after the younger man had had troubles with the law. Unfortunately, the younger Shafer repaid the trust by beating his dad to death.

Evil Lives Here airs Sundays at 9/8c on Investigation Discovery.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

Re the episode about the woman who aborted two pregnancies by killing them, I don’t know who was crazier, the woman, who was obviously sick, or her boyfriend, who in real life has got to be one of the weakest, most oblivious people on earth. How ANYONE can see all the evidence that this woman was nuts and pregnant, and simply choose to ignore it all—what a sad excuse for a man.

1 year ago

Why are you guys calling a black person a hoodlum and you have a million white people doing more crazier things. This page is racist. Call white people hoodlums too

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x